Guest Who? Emmys Edition

We at the HSB continue to share our thoughts about the 2010 Emmy Nominations. Next on the list: guest actors! As we've mentioned before, a good guest actor can blend seamlessly into a show, enhancing its strengths and downplaying its weaknesses. A good guest actor is one you want to see again. Unfortunately, producers and the like often get confused about the difference between casting a great guest actor and stunt-casting a really, really famous person. Not all star appearances are good, and not all good guest appearances are by big names. Here's how the 2010 nominations rank next to 2009:

Emmys Sidebar: the Voting Process

Every year we complain about the laziness of the Emmy voters. Here's a suggestion: why not require the voters to watch at least partial episodes -clips, even - of every show submitted in categories where they intend to cast their votes? My late stepmother was a member of the Television Academy, and I can verify that she definitely didn't watch every screener that came her way. (In fact, I was introduced to several television series through viewing of her unwanted screeners). After all, it's no surprise that voters choose established shows and actors for their ballots when they have little to no knowledge of the alternatives.

Barring that extreme, how about including critical input in the voting process? If these awards are truly meant to reflect the best in television, why not give the critics' opinions some weight? I'd trust Alan Sepinwall or the Entertainment Weekly staff any day over your average industry voter.

Hollywood: let's get on this!

2010 Emmy Nominations II: Supporting Boogaloo

Earlier we posted thoughts on the major category nominations for this year's Emmy Awards. Many of the best shows out there, however, are ensembles. Only one man and one woman can be nominated as leads for a given series, but there's no limit on the number of supporting nominations for a show -- so these categories are where the really outstanding casts get to shine. At least theoretically. All too often, the supporting nominations mirror the lead nominations - established shows, famous actors, etcetera, etcetera ...

Here are the HSB's thoughts on the 2010 Supporting Actor nominations, and how they stack up to last year's nods:

2010 Emmy Nominations

Today the 2010 Emmy nominations were announced. Pop culture junkies are already poring over the list for snubs and—less often—happy surprises. The Academy is notorious for out-of-touch nominations and omissions that leave tv critics weeping. Hollywood Suggestion Box wonders: Has the Academy learned anything since last year?

Get This Man An Emmy: Zach Gilford

For those of us who have watched and loved the last three seasons of Friday Night Lights, it's been incredibly frustrating to watch the Television Academy snub the show and its superlative writing, acting and directing time after time. Connie Britten and Kyle Chandler, as well as supporting cast members like Taylor Kitsch and minor players like Brad Leland and Louanne Stephens, are so naturalistic that I sometimes think that the Academy voters must be confused and mistake the show for a documentary. Like The Wire, it's too good for its own good.